15 ATS players made the Round 10 watchlist from 117 qualifiers across three games. It’s a mix of a couple of short-priced stars where the market is basically right, a few favourites that look a touch too short, and a stack of middle/bench forwards priced like they never crash over — even though their role says they absolutely can.
Round 10’s ATS menu is very “NRL-core”: Storm are expected to roll, Penrith are Penrith, and Manly v Brisbane has enough moving parts to make pricing messy.
This watchlist is player-led and price-led. We’re not trying to pick 15 “most likely” try scorers — we’re trying to find the players whose role and scoring path are being underpaid by the market (and flag the ones being overcharged). Remember: anytime try scorers are high-variance by nature. You’re buying a story that needs to happen, not a guarantee.
Published
Thu, 7 May, 8:11 am UTC
Updated
Sat, 9 May, 7:46 am UTC
Data refreshed
Sat, 9 May, 7:46 am UTC
Patrick Carrigan
Brisbane Broncos • Lock
Carrigan at a double-digit quote is the kind of middle-forward ATS number that makes you sit up — not because he’s suddenly a winger, but because his involvement gives him more scoring paths than the market tends to price in.
Scoring path
Footylab likes the opportunity here: his profile rates strongly for being around the ball in the right areas, and he’s got enough explosiveness to turn a half-chance into points. That’s the key with locks — you’re not relying on a backline sweep; you’re relying on repeat sets, a quick play-the-ball, and a middle runner hitting the line with intent.
Price view
At around $12, the market is basically saying “needs a lot to go right.” Footylab’s fair price is shorter (closer to $11), which is enough of a gap to call it value in a volatile market. If you’re playing long shots, this is the type you want: role-driven, not miracle-driven.
Latest news
Availability matters with these bets, and the judiciary note is worth having in the back pocket when you’re finalising any card.
Source: NRL Judiciary: Cogger accepts ban; Staggs cops two weeks
Footylab signal
Patrick Carrigan is strong value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +59.5 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
12.00
Bet Right
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
59.5 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
56.03
Best quoted bookmaker: Bet Right
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 5.00, so line shopping matters.
Taniela Paseka
Manly Warringah Sea Eagles • Prop
Paseka is the classic “prop at a price” play: not sexy, but the try-scoring route is obvious when Manly are rolling and the game turns into repeat sets on the line.
Scoring path
The appeal is the environment more than anything — Footylab rates Manly’s attacking setup well for creating those short-range chances, and the opponent profile isn’t screaming “brick wall” either. Add in Paseka’s recent scoring form being healthier than you’d expect for a front-rower, and you’ve got a legitimate crash-over candidate.
Price view
The $12 quote is doing the usual thing props get: priced like they need a freak play. Footylab has him shorter again (fair closer to $10.6), so you’re being paid to take the ugly position.
Latest news
Manly’s pack/bench mix can matter for middle minutes and who gets the prime carries near the stripe.
Source: Injury Report Corey Waddell
Footylab signal
Taniela Paseka is strong value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +54.1 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
12.00
Bet Right
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
54.1 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
55.45
Best quoted bookmaker: Bet Right
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 5.50, so line shopping matters.
Royce Hunt
Wests Tigers • Interchange
If you’re going to throw a dart at a Tigers try scorer against Melbourne, you want it to be someone whose scoring isn’t totally dependent on the Tigers looking like the Storm. Hunt fits that brief better than most.
Scoring path
Footylab’s base scoring and recent try form both rate strongly for him, which is a nice combo for a bench middle: it suggests he’s not just “making tackles,” he’s actually getting the kind of carries that can turn into a line crash when the game state allows it. Even in tough matchups, bench middles can jag one off momentum swings or late fatigue.
Price view
The market is dangling $12, while Footylab’s fair price is notably shorter (around $9.3). That’s a meaningful gap for an ATS play — you’re not trying to be right often, you’re trying to be paid properly when you are.
Latest news
Keep an eye on forward availability/rotation notes, because bench roles can change quickly week to week.
Footylab signal
Royce Hunt is strong value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +50.8 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
12.00
PointsBet (AU)
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
50.8 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
55.74
Best quoted bookmaker: PointsBet (AU)
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 7.00, so line shopping matters.
Terrell May
Wests Tigers • Prop
May is priced like a genuine chance to score for a prop — and Footylab agrees. This isn’t a “value because it’s big” play; it’s a “value because the role keeps putting him in the frame” play.
Scoring path
The opportunity rating is the headline: he’s getting enough involvement that a try isn’t some once-a-season event. Add solid recent form and a bit of punch (explosiveness is decent for a middle), and you’ve got a forward who can finish when the ruck gets messy.
Price view
$7.50 is still a long-ish number in ATS terms, but Footylab has him shorter again (fair around $7.0). It’s not a massive edge — it’s just the market being a touch conservative on a prop who’s clearly in the mix.
Footylab signal
Terrell May is strong value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +41.6 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
7.50
Unibet
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
41.6 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
56.71
Best quoted bookmaker: Unibet
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 1.50, so line shopping matters.
Corey Horsburgh
Canberra Raiders • Prop
Horsburgh is the type of Raider you consider in ATS when you think Canberra’s best chance of hurting Penrith is through effort and repeat sets, not pretty shapes.
Scoring path
Footylab’s lean comes from a balanced profile: he’s not just “maybe he falls over the line.” There’s enough opportunity and base involvement to keep him relevant, and his recent try-scoring form is better than the market usually prices for a prop in a tough matchup.
Price view
At $12, you’re being asked to accept the Penrith factor — and fair enough. But Footylab still makes him shorter (fair around $10.4), which is why he lands as a value long shot rather than a pure vibes play.
Footylab signal
Corey Horsburgh is strong value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +40.7 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
12.00
PointsBet (AU)
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
40.7 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
46.61
Best quoted bookmaker: PointsBet (AU)
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 5.50, so line shopping matters.
Sualauvi Faalogo
Melbourne Storm • Fullback
Faalogo is the definition of “short price for a reason.” If you want a Storm ATS anchor, he’s priced about where it should be.
Scoring path
Everything in the profile screams try scorer: elite base scoring, elite recent form, and the kind of explosiveness that turns half-breaks into points. Fullbacks in good attacking sides don’t need a set play — they just need the game to open up.
Price view
Around $1.65, the market isn’t giving you much margin for error, and Footylab basically agrees with the number (fair roughly $1.57). That’s not a “must bet,” it’s just a clean read: you’re not being ripped, but you’re not stealing it either.
Footylab signal
No strong signal.
Footylab is not calling this selection value or ripoff because the stats and market are close enough to sit inside the no-call band.
── Odds
Best odds
1.65
TAB
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
0.0 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
85.42
Best quoted bookmaker: TAB
Risk note
ATS markets stay volatile, so Sualauvi Faalogo still needs Melbourne Storm to create enough quality chances and a stable role against Wests Tigers for the price to cover the natural variance.
Dylan Edwards
Penrith Panthers • Fullback
Edwards is one of the few short-ish ATS prices that can still make sense, because his try involvement isn’t a hot streak — it’s baked into how Penrith play.
Scoring path
Footylab has him near the top of the slate for opportunity and recent form. That’s the Edwards story: constant support play, constant backing up through the middle, and enough speed to finish when the line cracks. Against teams that can be forced into scramble, he’s always live.
Price view
The market is around $1.96 and Footylab has him a touch shorter (fair about $1.88). It’s a small edge, but in ATS land you don’t often get “best player on the park” profiles at close to even money.
Footylab signal
Dylan Edwards is small value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +5.3 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
1.96
Ladbrokes
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
5.3 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
84.86
Best quoted bookmaker: Ladbrokes
Risk note
ATS markets stay volatile, so Dylan Edwards still needs Penrith Panthers to create enough quality chances and a stable role against Canberra Raiders for the price to cover the natural variance.
Lehi Hopoate
Manly Warringah Sea Eagles • Wing
Hopoate’s number is basically the market saying: “Yep, he’s a strong chance, and we’re not overthinking it.” Footylab’s read is the same.
Scoring path
The winger profile is as clean as it gets — elite recent form, strong base involvement for an outside back, and enough opportunity to keep him in the finish of Manly’s good-ball sets. When Manly are humming, their wingers don’t need many touches to get paid.
Price view
At about $1.80 with a fair price sitting in the same neighbourhood (around $1.75), there isn’t a big pricing argument either way. If you like it, you’re not donating. If you don’t, you’re not missing a glaring overlay.
Footylab signal
No strong signal.
Footylab is not calling this selection value or ripoff because the stats and market are close enough to sit inside the no-call band.
── Odds
Best odds
1.80
PointsBet (AU)
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
0.0 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
83.71
Best quoted bookmaker: PointsBet (AU)
Risk note
ATS markets stay volatile, so Lehi Hopoate still needs Manly Warringah Sea Eagles to create enough quality chances and a stable role against Brisbane Broncos for the price to cover the natural variance.
Daine Laurie
Canberra Raiders • Fullback
Laurie is the one the market has pushed too far out — and Footylab is basically calling that a mistake.
Scoring path
Even with a decent positional scoring profile, the rest of the setup isn’t doing him favours: Canberra’s attack environment grades poorly here, and the explosiveness rating is low. That’s a rough combo for a fullback ATS ticket, because you’re relying on broken play and support lines — and you need the team to generate those moments.
Price view
The market is dangling $7.50, but Footylab has him much shorter (fair around $4.8). That’s not a “tiny disagreement,” that’s a big one. If you trust the model’s view of his scoring routes, the current quote is the kind you’d normally chase.
Footylab signal
Daine Laurie is strong ripoff.
The current price asks for more than Footylab's stats support, with a -22.8 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
7.50
Bet Right
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
-22.8 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
34.62
Best quoted bookmaker: Bet Right
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 4.55, so line shopping matters.
Jake Simpkin
Manly Warringah Sea Eagles • Interchange
Simpkin is a sneaky Manly long shot because the price is built like he’s irrelevant — and bench hookers can be anything but, especially when the game turns into ruck chaos.
Scoring path
Footylab likes the overall attacking environment and gives him a decent explosiveness tick, with an opponent profile that doesn’t shut the door. The scoring path is simple: a quick dart from dummy-half close to the line, or being the link that gets the short ball back on a broken edge.
Price view
At $12, you’re being paid as if he needs a miracle. Footylab’s fair price is closer to $8.2, so there’s enough meat on the bone to justify the volatility.
Footylab signal
Jake Simpkin is small value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +8.1 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
12.00
Unibet
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
8.1 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
40.85
Best quoted bookmaker: Unibet
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 7.75, so line shopping matters.
Aublix Tawha
Brisbane Broncos • Reserve
Tawha is the opposite of what you want in a long-shot ATS: a big price that still doesn’t compensate for the uncertainty.
Scoring path
The underlying profile is weak across the key areas — low team attack environment, low explosiveness, and a poor positional scoring read. Even if the matchup isn’t terrifying, you still need a player to have a believable route to the stripe.
Price view
$12 looks tempting, but Footylab’s fair price is longer again (around $8.3) and the overall read is that you’re not being paid enough for the risk you’re taking.
Footylab signal
Aublix Tawha is strong ripoff.
The current price asks for more than Footylab's stats support, with a -24.3 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
12.00
Unibet
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
-24.3 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
26.18
Best quoted bookmaker: Unibet
Risk note
Stats reliability is only 60.0, which caps confidence. The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 6.50, so line shopping matters.
Morgan Smithies
Canberra Raiders • Lock
Smithies is a proper “price vs role” play. You’re not betting him because he’s a renowned finisher — you’re betting him because locks who get the right workload can jag tries at silly numbers.
Scoring path
The profile isn’t screaming elite, but it doesn’t need to. There’s enough opportunity and a workable positional scoring shape to justify the idea that he can be the beneficiary of repeat sets or a tired middle. Against a disciplined side, that’s often the only way Canberra score anyway: grind, earn the ruck, then punch.
Price view
At $15, the market is basically washing its hands of it. Footylab has him shorter (fair around $13.3) and tags it as strong value — not because it’s likely, but because the payout matches the reality better.
Latest news
Role matters a lot with this type of bet, and the late reshuffle note is a reminder that his usage can move.
Footylab signal
Morgan Smithies is strong value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +21.6 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
15.00
Bet Right
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
21.6 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
32.53
Best quoted bookmaker: Bet Right
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 7.50, so line shopping matters.
Alex Twal
Wests Tigers • Lock
Twal at $13 is the kind of number that looks ridiculous… right up until you remember how often locks score off pure persistence.
Scoring path
Footylab’s opportunity rating is the big tick — he’s in the contest enough to be a realistic beneficiary if the Tigers get any sustained pressure. The explosiveness isn’t elite, but it’s good enough for a middle-forward try: you don’t need footwork like a centre, you need timing and a straight line.
Price view
The market is around $13 and Footylab has him shorter (fair about $11). That’s a solid gap for a long shot, and it’s why he’s on the list even in a tough matchup.
Footylab signal
Alex Twal is strong value.
Footylab rates the chance higher than the current price implies, with a +38.2 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
13.00
PointsBet (AU)
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
38.2 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
41.84
Best quoted bookmaker: PointsBet (AU)
Risk note
The price is a long shot, so volatility is part of the case. Bookmaker quotes are spread by 6.00, so line shopping matters.
Will Warbrick
Melbourne Storm • Wing
Warbrick is a great try scorer. He’s also a great example of a price that doesn’t leave you much room to be wrong.
Scoring path
The underlying scoring profile is strong — high base rate, strong opportunity, and a winger role in a Storm side that creates chances. If you’re building a case for him, it’s easy: Melbourne generate width, and he can finish.
Price view
The issue is the number. Around $1.65, Footylab has him slightly longer (fair about $1.62), which is enough to call it a small “too short” rather than a full fade. In plain English: you’re paying top dollar in a market where even good wingers can go missing.
Footylab signal
Will Warbrick is small ripoff.
The current price asks for more than Footylab's stats support, with a -6.3 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
1.65
PointsBet (AU)
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
-6.3 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
72.27
Best quoted bookmaker: PointsBet (AU)
Risk note
ATS markets stay volatile, so Will Warbrick still needs Melbourne Storm to create enough quality chances and a stable role against Wests Tigers for the price to cover the natural variance.
Hugo Peel
Melbourne Storm • Wing
Peel is the one Storm winger price that looks like a trap: not because he can’t score, but because the market is asking you to ignore the uncertainty.
Scoring path
Footylab’s read is mixed: the positional profile is fine and the matchup isn’t a hard no, but the recent try form is poor and the overall confidence is limited. With wingers, you can survive one of those being shaky — not all of them at once.
Price view
At about $1.80, you’re being asked to treat him like a reliable finisher. Footylab has him shorter (fair around $1.74) but still flags this as a strong “ripoff” on the overall view, largely because the data confidence is low and the role sample is thin.
Footylab signal
Hugo Peel is strong ripoff.
The current price asks for more than Footylab's stats support, with a -68.4 pts edge.
── Odds
Best odds
1.80
Bet Right
Margin
N/A
── Win probability
Odds-implied win %
—
Stats-implied win %
—
Stats edge
-68.4 pts
── Stats context
Stats rating
35.08
Best quoted bookmaker: Bet Right
Risk note
Stats reliability is only 45.2, which caps confidence. Position sample size is only 3, so role certainty matters.
Conclusion
That’s the Round 10 ATS watchlist: a couple of “market’s about right” shorties (Faalogo, Hopoate), a small-edge star (Edwards), a few Storm prices that feel a touch too tight (Warbrick, Peel), and a bunch of forward long shots where the number is doing most of the heavy lifting.
If you’re playing this card, the practical move is simple: shop for the best quote on the long shots, and be ruthless about role certainty — bench minutes and late reshuffles are where ATS bets go to die.
Keep exploring
Follow the linked match pages for live market context or read the approach pages for how Footylab builds fair price and value scores.
Disclaimer
Footylab articles summarise cached market and stats inputs. They are informational only and are not betting advice.
